Fixed Fee vs Performance Fee in PMS: Which Is Right for You?
Portfolio Management Services (PMS) offer high-net-worth individuals like you a customized way to invest larger sums, often with more concentrated strategies than mutual funds. But one decision can make or break your long-term returns: the fee structure. In India, you’ll typically encounter a fixed management fee around 2–2.5% per year on your assets, or a performance-linked fee that takes a share of profits above a hurdle rate, backed by a high-water mark.
This guide is designed for you as an investor. It breaks down both options simply, walks through real-world scenarios, and helps you decide based on your goals, risk tolerance, and how you feel about fees in up and down markets.
Why Your PMS Fee Choice Shapes Your Wealth
Fees aren’t just a line item—they determine when and how much money leaves your portfolio, directly impacting compounding. A fixed fee takes a steady cut every year, giving you cost certainty but charging you even in tough markets. A performance fee takes little or nothing in weak years but can claim a big slice of gains in strong ones.
Your choice should align with your psychology: Do you hate paying fees when returns disappoint, or do you mind sharing upside if it means lower costs in flat years? Over 5–10 years, this can add up to lakhs or crores in difference.
The Main PMS Fee Models Explained
1) Fixed Management Fee
You pay a set percentage (often 2–2.5%) of your portfolio’s value annually, regardless of performance. It’s simple: if your portfolio is ₹1 crore, expect ₹2–2.5 lakh yearly, charged quarterly or monthly.
2) Performance Fee with Hurdle
Fees kick in only on profits exceeding a “hurdle” (e.g., 8–10%). A common setup: 20% of gains above the hurdle. A high-water mark ensures you don’t pay twice on recovering losses.
3) Hybrid Model
A lower fixed fee (e.g., 1%) plus performance fees over the hurdle. It balances predictability with upside sharing.
Essential Terms for Smart Decisions
Hurdle Rate
Minimum return needed before performance fees apply. Below it? Zero performance fee that year.
High-Water Mark (HWM)
Your portfolio’s all-time high (after fees). Fees only on new gains above this peak—protecting you from paying on mere recovery.
Crystallization
When fees are calculated and deducted (often annually). Frequent crystallization pulls money out sooner, hurting compounding.
See How Fees Play Out in Real Scenarios
Starting portfolio: ₹1 crore. Fixed fee: 2.5%. Performance: 20% above 8% hurdle + HWM.
Flat Year (0% Return)
- Fixed: ₹2.5 lakh fee.
- Performance: ₹0.
You save in weak years with performance fees.
Good Year (12% Return)
- Fixed: ₹2.5 lakh.
- Performance: ₹80,000 (20% of ₹4 lakh excess).
Performance cheaper here.
Bull Year (30% Return)
- Fixed: ₹2.5 lakh.
- Performance: ₹4.4 lakh.
Fixed wins big in strong markets.
Volatile Cycle (Year 1: -20%, Year 2: +30%)
Portfolio ends at ₹1.04 crore. HWM protects: performance fee only on true new gains, not recovery.
Choose Fixed Fee If…
- You want predictability: Know your costs upfront—no surprises.
- Simplicity matters: No need to track hurdles or HWMs.
- You’re fee-sensitive long-term: In cycles with big bull years, 2–2.5% often costs less overall than performance spikes.
- Your profile: Conservative/moderate risk, focused on steady growth over max upside.
Even at 2.5%, it suits if the PMS delivers reliable risk control worth the steady fee.
Choose Performance Fee If…
- Fairness in down years appeals: Pay little/nothing when markets lag.
- You chase alpha: Share upside only if the manager beats the hurdle consistently.
- Variability is fine: Okay with big fees in winners for alignment.
- Your profile: Aggressive, high-conviction in the strategy, comfortable with complexity.
Ideal with strong manager track records and clear terms.
Quick Comparison Table
Your 4-Step Decision Framework
- Assess Your Mindset: Hate fees in bad years? Go performance. Fear upside erosion? Go fixed.
- Match to Goals: Modest outperformance needed? Fixed. Big alpha expected? Performance.
- Scrutinize Terms: Demand examples for 4 scenarios. Confirm HWM, hurdle details, crystallization.
- Run Projections: Use PMS fee calculators for your ₹ amount over 5–10 years. Compare net wealth.
Final Thoughts: Make It Personal
No one-size-fits-all—fixed at 2–2.5% offers peace of mind and often lower cycle costs; performance with hurdle feels aligned but watch for spikes. Review the PMS disclosure document, run your numbers, and pick what lets you sleep easy through market swings. Your net wealth depends on staying invested long-term with a structure you trust.
Sign up now to access exclusive insights and download the full investor PPT to understand the strategy, minimum investment, MOIC, and IRR—clearly and simply.
